Jun 26 2008
“Eternity Road” by Jack McDevitt
Post-apocalyptic stories appeal to me. I’m not exactly sure why they do, but they really do. Maybe it’s the possibility of prophetic vision in such stories or just the dream (or nightmare) of what may lie in wait around that next corner that sets my mind a-spinnin’. I don’t much care for the same old fare though. Viruses, nuclear holocausts, asteroids, etc. These scenarios seem too convenient and much too short sighted. I much prefer to think in harsher, longer terms. Remember the movie Red Dawn, (not that great of a movie, but a pretty good story). The United States is invaded by globally connected communists and Americans are rounded up and forced into the “red” way of life. With a few brave souls heading to the mountains to keep fighting for peace, justice, and the American Way, blah blah blah… I want to know what the (former) USA is like 10 years, 100 years, 500 years after the events like those in the movie. That’s the kind of story I’d like to find… hmmm…
Eternity Road is not that story. It’s a basic virus-wiped-out-society-1000-or-so-years-ago story. Beyond that, there is little in this book that makes a whole lot of sense at all. I know, I know, this is Science Fiction, it’s not based in facts, but I would argue good Sci-Fi at least, at the very least, has to make sense. I agree we as readers must put our imaginations to work, we need to set aside a good bit of, if not all reality, we need to accept certain unbelievable things in order for the story to work. But it has to make sense, right?
So, without getting into too many details I’ll point out a few things that just didn’t work for me, but first the few things that did. I like the setting in America. I like the familiar names of places and geography…. but that’s where everything starts to go awry. Sure, there’s the Mississippi and Ohio rivers, but the Great Lakes have become The Inland Sea or something like that. The ruins of highways are still called highways, but cars are called hojiis and no one has ever in 1000 years figured out how to use them or how they worked or how any of the bridges or buildings or roads or anything was built. They have not re-discovered electricity yet they use coal, steam power, gunpowder, they manufacture firearms, ammunition, and build ornate structures. I mean, the things that are remembered and not remembered, just didn’t make sense to me. Oh, and one other thing, the awesome and fantastic society (our society) that this future quest searches to find more about decided the best place to store its histories was on paper, in a wet tidal cave, somewhere off the northeast coast… Ok, don’t get me started… before I ramble on too long, I’ll just go ahead and spell it out for you:
I read this book with great anticipation. I was immensely disappointed.
-=R=-
Ps. Can anyone recommend any good post-apocalyptic type stories out there? Suggestions? Recommendations? Anyone?
FINALLY! I finally finished this book last night. Now, if you read my last post written more than a month ago in the Las Vegas airport, you’re wondering how 200 pages left stretched into a month of reading. Me too. Not really,
Rating: 2**